It's Normal

July 28, 2020 by Dr. Sigrun Hackl

The little French Bulldog hobbles in with a wide stance and a stiff back, his breathing audible long before he reaches the door, his chunky body looks square. 

In any other being that noisy breathing would worry us, yet in the breed, ‘it’s normal’. The distressed look and wide open mouth to get as much cooling as possible would ring alarm bells in a normal faced canine, yet again, ‘they are always like this, it’s the breed’. And the posture and gait, indicating orthopaedic issues? Same answer. ‘It’s normal for the breed’.

But is it really?

It certainly isn’t from a medical point of view.

The brachycephalic (short nosed) breeds are very popular for their ‘cute’ round shaped heads, big eyes and often lively and playful characters. Yet the purposeful breeding for ‘cuteness’, shortening the nose to the extreme, has left them struggling for air from the moment they are born. I was shocked when, as a young vet, a bulldog breeder told me that he had an oxygen chamber at home as otherwise the puppies would not survive. It was around the same time that I learned that bulldogs do not give birth naturally as the heads of the puppies are too large for the mother’s small pelvis. They generally have a caesarean. Isn’t nature trying to tell us something here?

So we have created a being that cannot be born naturally. They cannot survive in the natural environment. And if they do make it through the initial 6 weeks of their life, they struggle for air their entire life. Do you remember the last time you had a severe cold and a blocked nose? Imagine that for life. 

The breeds have more inbred problems than any other breed, but are still unfalteringly popular, feeding into the system of demand creating a market. Proud owners tell me about the ‘long nose’ of their pug, that is still only a little snub. CT scans of their skulls show a total lack of nasal bone and nasal sinuses, an essential part of the cooling mechanism through panting. Since dogs cannot sweat, the regulation of their body temperature relies on cooling the blood through the large surface inside their nasal cavity. A surface that has been bred away, leading to a constant struggle for heat control in these dogs. 

The shortening of the face has created a long, soft palate (roof of the mouth), which narrows down the opening of the windpipe and creates the characteristic snoring sounds of the breeds. 

The pronounced nasal folds accumulate infections and require daily care. They push against the bulging eyes causing constant irritation and leading to permanent damage and even blindness of the eye over the years – remember the last time you had an eyelash in your eye? Consider it normal. 

In addition, many of them are prone for inborn deformations of the spine, predisposing them for back pain, spinal problems, disc prolapse and even paralyzed hind legs. 

Faced with all these issues the breeds will frequently struggle with exercise, either getting heat stroke, if they do try to run, or simply resolving to a sedentary life-style with little activity. Add to this the joy of food, and you end up with a chunky being that has a good layer of fat under his skin. Insulating fat, that will add to the heat control problem and close the vicious cycle. 

‘He is fat because he can’t exercise!’

Is that really a good reason? Isn’t that as much as saying ‘it’s normal’?

Shouldn’t we say ‘No! It is NOT normal’ instead?

 

But I have a bulldog, what do you want me to do now?

Well, of course, if you have one of them already, just make the best of the situation! Keep him happy, be aware of his inborn problems and look after them. Clean his skin folds and treat his eyes and watch his back, and PLEASE, KEEP HIM REALLY SLIM. It makes a huge difference to him on the orthopaedic side as well as the heat control. Keep him happy as long as you can! Being bred this way doesn’t make him any less lovable, just more in need of attention. 

And what can be done to stop them from suffering?

As always, it is the demand that creates the market. Only increased awareness of the situation can change things. Only if we stop buying, asking, calling it ‘normal’, the breeders will see no market and they will have to stop breeding them this way. Several countries are already trying to counteract the trend with stricter laws for animal protection, yet it’s really our ‘oh, he is so cute’, that keeps things running and makes him suffer for the way he was born. Those who see a market (and profit) will always find a loophole or escape to continue to breed them this way, unless WE, as customers, say NO! No more!

Please be aware that the ‘cute’ is an instinctive reaction, our brains being programmed to respond to the child like features and wanting to protect. This feature is common in mammals, and triggers the parenting instincts that have, over generations, ensured our survival as a species. We do have the power to decide against that instinct, once we are aware that ‘cute’ is not really ‘cute’ in this case. 

So when it comes to choosing a new member for the family, go for a long nose and stop the demand that creates the market. After all, you want a healthy baby for your family, and in brachycephalic breeds, ‘normal’, is not normal.

Picture of Dr. Sigrun Hackl

Dr. Sigrun Hackl

Veterinary Surgeon

Like? Share it with friends

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.